Skip to main content

Why Taylor Swift? Why?

So Taylor Swift's just put out the title track from her upcoming album Red.  It's a generic dance pop number that sounds like a limp version of Mariah Carey's Obsessed.  It makes the cute but ultimately mediocre We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together Again sound like a masterstroke.  Why would she resort to doing songs like this? She clearly hasn't lost her touch. Ronan, which she put out a few weeks ago, is absolutely brilliant. Hiring outside writers to make dance pop songs is just wrong for so many reasons.
  1. She's already one of the greatest songwriters of our time.  Sure, she's not the best, but I can count on one hand the number of people better than her (Drake, Kanye West, Kele Okereke of Bloc Party, Caleb Followill of Kings of Leon, and Matt Berninger of The National). There's no reason to hire help when you're already so damn good at what you do.
  2. Dance pop is completely saturated. There's Kesha, Katy Perry, Nicki Minaj, Rihanna, Ellie Goulding, Carly Rae Jepsen, Maroon 5, Christina Aguilera, Britney Spears, Rita Ora, Justin Bieber, Usher, and probably another dozen that I've forgotten. Country, on the other hand, is a wasteland. Last year, I think the entire genre produced two good song: Eric Church's Springsteen and Pistol Annies' Hell on Heels. Why leave a genre where you have virtually no competition for the most saturated genre in popular music?
  3. Dance pop doesn't play at all to her strengths.  The melodies she's good at writing are too subtle for dance pop, as are her lyrics. Also, her voice is too soft and sweet to carry the tracks.
Basically, if you're Nelly Furtado and you're a one hit wonder who's just released a dud album, I can totally understand hooking up with Timbaland, completely changing your sound, and going for a hit.  On the other hand, if you're a superstar whose last single was Ours, a brilliant, sweet, charming, successful, self-written country-pop song, don't rock the boat.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Greatest Song of All Time

The music business has its fair share of complexities, as you would expect from any business with such a long history, and that is, at its core, built upon international law (i.e. copyright). That complexity is almost always hidden from the listening public. However, one piece that is curiously exposed every year when the Grammys come around is the separation between what is a "record" and what is a "song". The second and third most prestigious awards at the Grammys are, respectively, "Song of the Year," and "Record of the Year." What's the difference? Most people, including most musicians, wouldn't be able to tell you. I couldn't either until I took a music industry course in college where someone finally explained it to me: A "song" is melody and lyrics. The best way I have to think if it is, if hear someone play a faithful-to-the-original, acoustic cover, the "song" is what would be the same between the orig...

Best Musical Snippets of 2013

It's always great when you get a song that's consistently great from beginning to end, but sometimes it doesn't work out that way.  Sometimes you get songs where a certain section clearly stands out from the rest. Here's a few from this year: The Chorus of Kanye West's Bound 2 : The soul sample that occupies the rest of the song is soul only in name.  It approximates College Dropout-era Kanye with none of the warmth and, well, soul that made those tracks great.  The chorus is the exact opposite.  It uses the electronic music technique of putting a soulful male voice over a bass-heavy beat to create something emotive and genuinely soulful. The 3rd Minute of Youth Lagoon's Mute : Most of the song is nothing but warm, hazy fuzz, but, for about a minute, Trevor Powers cuts through that fuzz with a soaring, uplifting melody that Bono would be jealous of. The Pre-Chorus of Vampire Weekend's Unbelievers : One of two things this year that absolutely blew me away...

Top 10 Albums of 2011

At the end of the year, every single music publication put out a list of their top albums.  Who am I to buck the trend?  So, here's my list of the ten best albums of 2011.  I also included the score out of 10 for each album.  Here's what those mean: 10 - Top 40 Albums of All Time 9   - Classic 8   - Album of the Year Candidate 7   - Amazing 6   - Excellent 5   - Very Good 4   - Good 3   - Passable 2   - A Few Good Songs 1   - One Good Song 0   - Entirely Unremarkable Also, here's a Spotify playlist of all the good songs from the 6 of the 10 albums below.  Nostalgia, Ultra. and House of Balloons are left out because they were free mixtapes and are thus not out on Spotify.  Just download them, legally and for free, using the links below.  21 and Mylo Xyloto are left out because they're making too much money to be worth putting on Spotify, so I guess you'll have to just buy them...