Skip to main content

Review: Taylor Swift - Red

Songwriting genius usually lasts only a few years.  Take the greatest songwriters of all time, Paul McCartney and John Lennon. They couldn't write a bad song from 1965-1969.  Afterwards, they couldn't even manage another half dozen. Or Eminem. He had the greatest run in rap history from 1999-2002.  Since then, his music output has been almost entirely crap.

There are some exceptions.  For example, Bono of U2 wrote great songs at a steady clip from 1984 all the way to 2004.  Unfortunately, Taylor Swift is not one of them.  Over the past half decade, she's had the best run in country music history.  That run ends here.  That's not so say Red is a bad album.  It's not. It's a very good adult pop album. It's just that the genius isn't there anymore. There's no "Teardrops on My Guitar," no "Love Story," no "Back to December."  The best we get is "Begin Again" and "The Lucky One."  Both of them are well-written, but neither would've even made the top three on any of her previous albums.

On the bright side, she's broadened her horizons:
  1. She wrote three dance pop songs with Max Martin. The first of them, "I Knew You Were Trouble," is actually rather decent, once you get over the oddity of Taylor Swift singing over a dubstep backing track.
  2. She dabbles in arena rock.  "State of Grace," in particular, with its chiming guitars and and mediocre songwriting, is a dead ringer for a modern U2 song.
  3. Gary Lightbody of Snow Patrol and Ed Sheeran, who have written a combined total of one good song over the past half decade, happily lend their mediocrity to the proceedings.  [On a related note, Snow Patrol's Eyes Open (the one with Chasing Cars) is one of the greatest albums of all time. Listen to it if you haven't already.]
All of this makes Red a more diverse and interesting listen, but ends up having no lasting value.  Basically, of her four albums, Red sounds by far the best on the first listen and by far the worst by the fourth

Bonus: As I was going through Red, I came across this song: "I'd Lie."  It's a lyrical and melodic tour de force that blows every song on Red out of the water.  Apparently, it got left off of her first album in an act of criminal negligence by her record label.  Have a listen.

tl;dr: Red is not bad, but it's her worst. "Begin Again" and "The Lucky One" are solid though

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Greatest Song of All Time

The music business has its fair share of complexities, as you would expect from any business with such a long history, and that is, at its core, built upon international law (i.e. copyright). That complexity is almost always hidden from the listening public. However, one piece that is curiously exposed every year when the Grammys come around is the separation between what is a "record" and what is a "song". The second and third most prestigious awards at the Grammys are, respectively, "Song of the Year," and "Record of the Year." What's the difference? Most people, including most musicians, wouldn't be able to tell you. I couldn't either until I took a music industry course in college where someone finally explained it to me: A "song" is melody and lyrics. The best way I have to think if it is, if hear someone play a faithful-to-the-original, acoustic cover, the "song" is what would be the same between the orig...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Best of the Brits

Coldplay just released a new song, "Paradise", from their forthcoming album, Mylo Xyloto, and it's actually really good.  Leagues better than Every Teardrop is a Waterfall.  Heck, it's better than anything off of Viva la Vida except for "Viva la Vida".  Anyways, that got me thinking about all the great pop music that the Brits have come up with over the past couple years that never made it across the pond.  So, here's a list of a few of the best ones: The Wanted - All Time Low (Genre: Pop): Boy bands and girl groups might've died in the U.S., but they're still going strong in the UK with acts like Girls Aloud, The Saturdays, JLS, and, god have mercy, Jedward.  (Seriously, if you think American music is bad, just look up Jedward.  They might be cute little kids but I want to strangle both of them at least three times over and punt them to Pluto.)  Anyways, the best song any of them has managed to put out in the past few years is The Wanted'...
Post a Comment
Read more

Best of The X-Factor UK

This coming Wednesday, Simon Cowell's replacement for American Idol, The X Factor, will debut here in the states. So, here's my favorite moments from the UK X-Factor, in the hopes that the US version will have moments just as good. Cher Lloyd - Turn My Swag On : A cheeky British teenager (16 at the time) covers the Keri Hilson cover of a Soulja Boy song.  On paper, it should've been a complete joke, but, somehow, Cher made it work.  She totally had the attitude, the look, and the voice to pull it off, and it didn't hurt that the song was actually awesome. Hands down the best and the most unique audition I've ever seen on any of these reality singing shows.   Jamie Archer - Sex on Fire : The song was a huge hit in the UK and an even bigger hit in Australia.  How it never became a hit in the US is beyond me.  Anyways, Jamie Archer has a perfect voice for the song and he just fucking sells it.  I can't help but smile watching this, and, judging by the vide...
Post a Comment
Read more