Skip to main content

Review: Taylor Swift - Red

Songwriting genius usually lasts only a few years.  Take the greatest songwriters of all time, Paul McCartney and John Lennon. They couldn't write a bad song from 1965-1969.  Afterwards, they couldn't even manage another half dozen. Or Eminem. He had the greatest run in rap history from 1999-2002.  Since then, his music output has been almost entirely crap.

There are some exceptions.  For example, Bono of U2 wrote great songs at a steady clip from 1984 all the way to 2004.  Unfortunately, Taylor Swift is not one of them.  Over the past half decade, she's had the best run in country music history.  That run ends here.  That's not so say Red is a bad album.  It's not. It's a very good adult pop album. It's just that the genius isn't there anymore. There's no "Teardrops on My Guitar," no "Love Story," no "Back to December."  The best we get is "Begin Again" and "The Lucky One."  Both of them are well-written, but neither would've even made the top three on any of her previous albums.

On the bright side, she's broadened her horizons:
  1. She wrote three dance pop songs with Max Martin. The first of them, "I Knew You Were Trouble," is actually rather decent, once you get over the oddity of Taylor Swift singing over a dubstep backing track.
  2. She dabbles in arena rock.  "State of Grace," in particular, with its chiming guitars and and mediocre songwriting, is a dead ringer for a modern U2 song.
  3. Gary Lightbody of Snow Patrol and Ed Sheeran, who have written a combined total of one good song over the past half decade, happily lend their mediocrity to the proceedings.  [On a related note, Snow Patrol's Eyes Open (the one with Chasing Cars) is one of the greatest albums of all time. Listen to it if you haven't already.]
All of this makes Red a more diverse and interesting listen, but ends up having no lasting value.  Basically, of her four albums, Red sounds by far the best on the first listen and by far the worst by the fourth

Bonus: As I was going through Red, I came across this song: "I'd Lie."  It's a lyrical and melodic tour de force that blows every song on Red out of the water.  Apparently, it got left off of her first album in an act of criminal negligence by her record label.  Have a listen.

tl;dr: Red is not bad, but it's her worst. "Begin Again" and "The Lucky One" are solid though

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Lists 4 Bitches

Now, for some actual music.  First, my last.fm account if you want a quick snapshot of what I like.  (Yes, I know, the name is stupid, go ahead and laugh, I don't care...)  Also, I made you bitches a list...bitches love lists... Top 10 Songs of 2011 (so far): The Weeknd - Wicked Games :   This song is perfect.  The best track off of the most interesting album to come out this year (It's also free, you should download it and give it a listen if you haven't already: Link ).  The overblown drums and grimy guitars give the song a lot of momentum and a great ambiance, but really, the song is all about Abel Tesfaye.  His voice is hauntingly perfect (or perfectly haunting, either one works) and his songwriting is on point all the way through.  I tried to pick the best part of this song, but I just can't.  It's that good. Tyler, The Creator - Yonkers : Should have won Video of the Year.  At least he won Best New Artist. Kid deserved it. His mom looked so proud. Anywa
1 comment
Read more

Songs That Should Have Been Hits

When releasing pop songs, major labels have been surprisingly good.  Sure, they often go with the obvious choices: the songs produced by famous producers and the songs featuring other big name acts.  However, after some bumbling around, they usually do end up releasing all the good songs as singles.  Every once in a while, though, they mess up big time.  Top 10 singles that could make millions of dollars and sometimes change the course of an artist's career are left to languish as album cuts because people are too stupid to comprehend their greatness.  Here's a list of songs that would conquer the world, if only someone would bother releasing them, and their likely peak chart position in the U.S.  There's links to YouTube videos of the songs imbedded below (obviously, there are some quality issues), and here's a Spotify Playlist with all available songs. Katy Perry - Hummingbird Heartbeat : #1 Jennifer Lopez - Hypnotico : #1 (Note: The YouTube video is sped up.)
1 comment
Read more

New Albums [9/13]

This week's a pretty good one for new releases.  Girls' Father, Son, Holy Ghost as well as St. Vincent's Strange Mercy will be officially released.  I've listened through both of them, and I thought I'd give them both a quick review. Girls - Father, Son, Holy Ghost: Girls is a San Francisco band, whose singer had a fucked up childhood in the Children of God cult, that makes ramshackle, charming, lo-fi, Beach Boys-sounding rock music. If you haven't heard their music, listen to Lust for Life , Laura , and/or Hellhole Ratrace off their first album (which was terribly titled as "Album").  Anyways, this album is definitely more expensive sounding than their debut, with more intricate and varied arrangements.  However, the songwriting is just not there.  I listened through the whole thing twice and found nothing to like.  Ironically, the only song that didn't make me want to vomit was the one called Vomit.  For that, I'll give this album a point
1 comment
Read more